THE BOOK FAIR
READ AND FULFILL YOUR LIFE
Thrity Umrigar
The Space Between Us
Author: Thrity Umrigar
Published: 2005
Genre: Novel; Cultural
Cover: Paperback
Pages: 321
Review:
Sera and Bhima, two very different women, are bound by gender but separated by class. Sera Dubash, Persian, lives in a comfortable middleclass home which is cleaned and tended by Bhima, her Indian servant, of many years.
Bhima lives in the stank squalor of the slums. She makes the trip each day to Sera’s home and cleans her house, furniture, utensils and toilet without thought, revulsion, or question.
Yet, after the many years of Bhima’s service, Sera cannot bear Bhima to eat from her utensils or relax on her furniture. Sera is disgusted by the way Bhima sits back on her haunches instead of using a chair, and is further repulsed by her chewing and spitting of tobacco.
Sera, a widow since the death of her husband Feroz, is devoted to her daughter, Dinaz, and son in law, Viraf, but also takes responsibility for Bhima’s granddaughter, Maya. She believes Maya, a smart girl who should have an education.
In spite of their different stations in life, Sera and Bhima each understand the needs of the other, and share moments that bind their lives. It was the two of them who spoke in hushed voices not to arouse the temper of Feroz. It was Bhima who comforted Sera after she suffered her husband’s beatings. And it is Sera who paid Maya’s schooling. When Bhima discloses her shame of Maya’s pregnancy, it is Sera who offers Maya a way out. Sera and Bhima both want to know who the father is, but Maya refuses to say.
“The Space Between Us,” a stunning work of literary art expresses sensitive, meaningful, relationships between women. The author describes class differences with amazing descriptive imagery, and depicts the misery of slum dwellers in realistic clarity. Beautifully written. Recommended.
The Secrets Between Us
Author: Thrity Umrigar
Published: 2018
Genre: Novel
Cover: Paperback
Pages: 368
Sympathetic, lively, colorful, characters dominate the novel of women whose lives depend on the kindness and integrity of the men in their lives. Complex relationships cross culture, religion, ethnicity and class structure. Dire poverty resides in the midst of glittering wealth.
The central characters reside in the underbelly of the Mumbai. Each individual struggles to survive the unrelenting poverty, poverty that pulls one into a depth of misery that one can only overcome by the willingness to help another, with less than oneself.
Through the connecting relationships, the figures gain depth and reveal their different tragedies. The author puts forth the theme that an event, though tragic for one, opens opportunity for another. As the characters struggle to break the cycle of poverty, the ideas of entrepreneurship, social equality and justice take hold.
Although written as a sequel, the book stands easily on its own. The story flows smoothly and quickly despite the mild, pervasive melodrama.